Developer: NANA Stories
Publisher: Dolores Entertainment
Platform: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox Series X|S, Switch (2)
Tested on: Switch 2
Love Love Mystery Club – Review
We’re slightly late with our review of Love Love Mystery Club on the Switch, as the game appropriately debuted on the platform right before Halloween. Of course, if you’re a true horror fan, you’ll appreciate scary games outside of the ‘official’ spooky season too, and boy, have we got a doozy for you. Love Love Mystery Club is billed as the very first FMV game from Thailand. This also means that it leans into Thai horror, which has its own distinct flavour, and probably makes the game worth checking out for genre fans. Of course, being first doesn’t necessarily equate to being good. How does Love Love Mystery Club fare?
Story
Set in a Thai high school, Love Love Mystery Club’s story is told from the perspective of Tuay, a student. Because joining a school club is mandatory to graduate, requiring at least one full semester of participation, Tuay joins the Occult Club under the misguided assumption that it will be the most chill option. However, Tuay can see spirits, something that is quickly picked up on by fellow club member Fern, who is particularly interested in ghosts. She sees the key to figuring out seven supernatural mysteries in Tuay. Together with the third club member, Jack, they investigate the spooky stories surrounding the school. Alongside Fern (and Jack), Tuay also meets several girls at the school. Each of them has ties to the supernatural mysteries that the Occult Club investigates… but they’re also potential love interests for Tuay.
The story blends horror, romance, and comedy, using school ghost stories to reflect upon the real struggles of teenage life, like the pressure of being outstanding, the pain of pursuing your dreams, and image and identity conflicts. Given that the driving force behind Love Love Mystery Club is its mysteries, we won’t go into too many details here, though to give you a brief idea of what to expect, we’ll tell you that you’ll investigate a librarian ghost, forbidden curses in the art room, dark secrets in the science lab, and even student suicide mythologies. While Love Love Mystery Club’s writing is generally good, time limitations do cause storylines to jump and end abruptly, with captions that don’t quite seem to cover what the story tries to say.
Graphics
Being an FMV game, Love Love Mystery Club uses video footage. The game features a streaming series aesthetic, with decent enough special effects for its supernatural elements. The production values are above average for what we’ve seen from other FMV games. We did notice that there were some continuity issues, with characters suddenly switching sides between cuts, doors that open and close inconsistently, and lighting rapidly shifting, which did undermine our suspension of disbelief. There were also some issues with performance, which surprised us given that this is, in essence, just a series of videos playing. Early on in the game though, when Tuay encountered a spirit for the first time, the footage froze for a couple of seconds unintentionally, while the audio kept playing and subtitles kept going.
Sound
The interesting thing about watching video footage in a language you’re not fluent in (or don’t speak at all) is that a lot of nuance is inevitably lost. Because of this, it’s often easier to misjudge “bad” acting performances compared to seeing actors that talk in your own native language. As such, we’re not entirely comfortable with criticising the actors, but to us their performances came across as inconsistent and sometimes pained or exaggerated, though this may just be a cultural difference between how acting is perceived in Thailand compared to the West. On the soundtrack front, Love Love Mystery Club’s background music is generally unremarkable, though the theme song stands out, as do the music videos for characters with whom Tuay achieves a high enough relationship score.
Gameplay
As is typically the case for the genre, Love Love Mystery Club’s gameplay is limited. It primarily involves watching video segments from Tuay’s point of view, interacting with characters and choosing dialogue options at specific narrative junctures. The game is structured around a daily cycle divided into two periods. During the day, you explore school life and bond with other students, and at night, you investigate mystery cases. Exploration feels very reminiscent of the Ace Attorney series, with the option to look around the environment and select interactive spots. A story tab on the right side of the screen tracks completed segments, while a timeline feature tracks branching paths and previous choices. The game follows an episodic structure, and at the end of each episode you’ll receive a score across your stats, including relationship ratings for each character.
While the branching choices and timeline tracking are adequate enough, Love Love Mystery Club’s checkpoint and replay system are annoyingly rigid, forcing you to repeat segments due to bad choices. This is the kind of game that is built around replaying and seeing how different choices play out, so more flexibility in this regard would have been welcome. Our first playthrough of Love Love Mystery Club took around five hours, which is fairly standard for an FMV title, and the €19.99 price of entry positions the game alongside Wales Interactive’s offerings like Who Pressed Mute on Uncle Marcus or Mia and the Dragon Princess. We’d say that Love Love Mystery Club is priced just right, though the appeal of the game’s blend of mystery horror and dating sim is perhaps more niche than that of other modern-day FMV titles.
Conclusion
An unusual and ambitious genre entry, Love Love Mystery Club successfully blends school horror, teen drama and self-aware comedy. While the production values are respectable, the overall experience is tempered somewhat by abrupt narrative pacing, minor technical flaws, and a rigid checkpoint system. We wouldn’t recommend the game as an entry FMV title, but if you’re a genre aficionado, you’ll find a lot to like here, provided the niche subject matter appeals to you, and you’re okay with overlooking the occasional technical issue.





No Comments